Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Phantom Critic #1's avatar

Another great essay JJ. Love your extended analogy with The Great Gatsby.

Expand full comment
Jim Packer's avatar

No it is not. But let me try to remember what I made the quote up from. (1) Atlas Shrugged itself, and the flapping jaws of the left as they perennially try to disassociate the under-mountain gassing scene from Hero Stalin's nth Five Year Plan (aka net zero intelligence) (2) [gosh, it was a whole universe of time ago] either Barbara Branden's Passion of Ayn Rand or James S. Valliant's The Passion of Ayn Rand's Critics (3) I think the self-referential "rectitude" turns up somewhere in The Romantic Manifesto.

In the 1980s, and slightly before, out of sheer right-wing self-pity (but I was also reading Scott Spencer and Patricia Highsmith!) I read the shrugging Atlas THREE TIMES. Did it make me a better person? It made me a better person than my (left-wing) brother, who read it only once. The Fountainhead is a better novel, and We the Living is better still. How odd that as the novels get worse and worse, they get stunningly more and more readable.

My sister was assistant to a number of dragon women in the public service, and one of them was Christine Nixon when she was Dep-Commissar at NSW Police. So I know that whereof I speak. When were those fires? Before Banalial Andrews? Yep, Vic has always sucked, but they got it from the convicts.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts